by demether » Sat Jul 26, 2014 3:47 pm
Hi,
First magnet HO cars are not "glued on rails". It's actually a very competitive way to race, because if the cars have more downforce, they are also a lot more faster. So deslot happens...And happens the hard way.
With lower voltage (and low power) these cars will never deslot. If you want to lower the voltage, you'll do exactly the opposite thing you want. You'll create boring races.
That's a question of balance between speed and track power and voltage. And of course, these fast cars need a fast and relatively big layout to be interesting.
Personnaly, I run (with many other things) tyco 440x2 magnets cars, with rubber standard tires, on my fast 13'x4' 4lanes track, and believe me there is no need for foam stops in controllers. The cars WILL deslot if the racer is not skilled enough. You cannot just pull the trigger.
But these fast magnet cars will not drift around corners, you're right. It's very hard to feel their limits.
The cool thing is (and a lot of slot racers doesn't know that) that HO scale have plenty of diferent chassis, for all tastes. Magnet cars are NOT the only choice in HO. And you even don't need to modify magnet chassis. Here's a little list of still produced stock chassis available :
thunderjet (or "tjet"). These cars will handle significantly the same as big scale non magnet cars. These cars have no real magnet traction, and skinny tires. They still are a very popular choice of ho slot cars. And cheap to race (thinking of race classes/categories) if you run them stock (with just slipon silicon tires).
These will drift in cornes, they have a very scaled speed (in stock version), and some inertia (especially without wired brake). Stock version (tuned, with at least slipon silicon tires) reminds me a out of box (but good) magnetless bigger scale slot car.
Xtraction (or older magnatraction). these cars are also still produced. ANd they are also really nice to run stock (after a minimal tuning like almost any slotcar). They don't have traction magnets, but their motor magnet is visible so it gives a bit more downforce than the tjets. The speed is faster than tjet, but handling is easier too since the chassis and tires wheels is wider. In stock form, the only hopup part really needed is a pair of slipon silicon tires, but it's not really necessary. It's also a cheap chassis choice.
The stock version (properly tuned) overal performance and handling reminds me a good magnetless 1/32 competition car.
There is other choices, from vintage brass chassis (tycopro, riggen, for example), to scratchbuilt chassis too.
There is also magnetless competition chassis like the one called "BSRT Gjet", but I never tested it.
Last choice is modified magnetcars to run magnetless. I made some tries myself (based on widepan 440X2), and people also modified more modern chassis like the MEGA G :
But the problem with modified chassis, at least in a commercial/club point of view, would be making all chassis reliable and close enough in performances.
Last thing : Some tjet and Xtraction releases came with a button-style traction magnet. Of course, the chassis I was speaking about are not these ones.