by slothead » Mon Jun 11, 2018 3:40 pm
Overall I understand racing cars against their siblings based on manufacturer, but in reality I can't resist matching cars by model and livery over make. In my Trans Am class while the field is mostly composed of Scalextric cars, the Pioneer cars are worthy competitors, and surprisingly the lone SCX AAR 'Cuda has also posted some excellent finishes. If there were more makes of Trans Am replica cars I'd probably have to have them too.
My World Sportscar class (Le Mans cars) contains mostly of FLy cars (Porsche, Ferrari, Lola, Ford) but there's also a Carerra Porsche 917, Scalextric Ferrari 330 P3 and Ford GT40's, and three MRRC Chaparral 2F's. It's a lot of fun to race all these cars against each other, and there is no clear favorite. The same goes for my newest series, Can-Am cars from '66 - '74. I have a HSRR McLaren running against Carrera Porsche cars, Monogram Mclarens and Lolas, and a bunch of Slot-It McLarens, Alfa Romeos, Ferrari 312s, and Chaparral 2E's. The biggest outlier is the new CG-Slotcars 3D printed Shadow DN4 - which after some work qualified 9th out of 21 cars. The top qualifier is a Slot-It Alfa Romeo 33/3 followed closely by a Monogram McLaren M6. After them a Slot-It Ferrari 312 is 3rd, a Fly Porsche 908 is the 4th place qualifier in the series. Three different makes in the top 4 positions.
In a club series I agree manufacturer based classes may be the best way to go. But for the way I simulate races as a solo racer being able to pit the top replicas and drivers against each other, across manufacturers is ideal and fairly set up they can all be competitive.